Verification tasks

Last updated: 21 Jan 2025

In the framework of WG5 verification activities, statistical scores are produced on a seasonal basis over Common Verification Areas and over national domains. For the station based approach (point verification), a Common Verification Software is used for all operational COSMO deterministic models. On the other hand, the evaluation with fuzzy (neighborhood) spatial methods is performed with VAST software over common areas. The technical details and the specifications of the verification analysis, are available in the guidelines which are prepared on an annual basis by the WG5C.

Point-wise Verification

The preparation of Common Plots based on Feedback Files is performed with the MEC/FFV2 (Rfdbk) statistical framework and they can be viewed interactively in the links below:

continuous parameters

domain average, against SYNOP stations.

continuous: geographical plots

station average.

continuous: time series

domain average.

categorical parameters

domain average, against SYNOP stations.

categorical: geographical plots

station average.

upper air

domain average, against TEMP stations.

upper air: geographical plots

station average.

upper air: time series

domain average.

The verification files that can be viewed through the links above, follow a naming protocol that is described in this document.

Fuzzy (neighborhood method) Verification

Fuzzy (spatial) verification (scores for precipitation forecasts are calculated over ComA-2 and ComA-3 for higher resolution operational deterministic models that cover the areas. The comparison is performed against the OPERA network radar composites. For this activity, VAST COSMO software is used that is based on Beth Ebert fuzzy verification IDL code.

ComA-2 ComA-3

On the menu, plots of ETS, FBI, FSS, POD and FAR scores are provided on a seasonal basis for two forecast days based on 00UTC forecast cycle.

 
 

EPS Verification

The statistical evaluation of the operational ensemble systems will become available from October 2024 onwards:

surface parameters

domain average, against SYNOP stations.

surface: geographical plots

station average.

surface: time series

domain average.

upper air

domain average, against TEMP stations.

upper air: geographical plots

station average.

upper air: time series

domain average.

Verification documentation

user guide

description of the usage of the web-based tool and the interpretation of the shown scores.

data format

Feedback File Definition (pdf, Harald Anlauf & Andreas Rhodin, 2019).

guidelines

Feedback File Verification Suite at DWD (Felix Fundel, 2022).

training

Feedback File Verification Training Course (Felix Fundel, 2019).

 

Verification analysis based on point-wise verification prior to Aug 2021 (VERSUS and MEC-Rfdbk software derived), can be viewed through older-style plots.